Honeybees are capable of simple math
The survival of the honeybee has been a worldwide concern over the last 10 years. This concern is warranted, since one-third of all food Americans eat is directly or indirectly derived from the honeybee population. The honeybee is an incredible insect, as they fly the equivalent of one and a half times the circumference of the Earth in their lifetime, which is only six to eight weeks long. Another amazing feat, is that honeybees have the ability to do simple addition and subtraction.
A new study from a team of Australian and French scientists have determined that bees are able to do basic arithmetic, even with their miniature brain. Arithmetic operations such as addition and subtraction problems are known to involve complex cognitive processes as they require two levels of information processing. The first is the representation of numerical attributes, and the second is the mental manipulation of those representations in working memory. The study was conducted in such a way that the bees needed to remember the initial problem in order to determine the correct answer.
In the study, 14 bees were trained to enter a Y-maze and view a sample problem which included a number of colored boxes of various shapes. The color of the boxes are associated with either addition (blue) or subtraction (yellow). The initial posting of shapes and colors are on the outside of the chamber, indicating the problem. Once inside the chamber, the bee then has the choice of two openings with colored boxes next to each opening. One opening is correct, and the other is incorrect. For example, a bee approaches the front of the chamber, which has three yellow boxes next to the opening. The bee then proceeds through the chamber into a room that has two openings. Next to one of the openings are two yellow boxes and the other has four yellow boxes. The bee would then fly through the opening with two boxes to achieve a correct answer. A diagram of the apparatus is below.
Figure: Experimental apparatus used to train and test free-flying bees on their capacity to learn addition and subtraction. Figure A is set up for subtraction trials, and Figure B is set up for addition trials.
Figure Credit: RMIT University
The training phase consisted of 100 rounds, where the 14 bees were given either a sucrose (reward) or a quinine (punishment) solution that was dependent on if their choice was correct or incorrect. Over the course of this phase, the bees learned the appropriate arithmetic rather quickly, going from less than 50% success to near 80%. The testing phase included four trials that did not incorporate a reward or punishment solution after they answered. Each bee has four math problems to brood over, two addition and two subtraction.
Image: Results of the learning and testing phases. Figure A is the performance during the learning phase. Figure B is the performance during the testing phases for addition and subtraction. The pink and green columns represent the distinct test, where 1,2,3, and 4 were the specific tests. Tests: 1) Sample = 3, correct = 4, incorrect = 5 2) Sample = 3, correct = 4, incorrect = 2 3) Sample = 3, correct = 2, incorrect = 1 4) Sample = 3, correct = 2, incorrect = 4. The direction (same, opposite) is describing when the correct answer was moved from one side of the y-shaped apparatus to the other. Same indicates that the correct answer from 1) to 2) was not moved. Opposite indicates that the correct answer from 1) to 2) was swapped to the other side.
Image Credit: RMIT Univserity
Through the testing phase, it was found that the correct answer was obtained between 70-75% of the time over all four questions. This study demonstrates that honeybees are capable of learning and applying numerical cognition as individuals. This study also suggests that honeybees and other animals may be biologically tuned for complex numerical tasks. The numbers that were used only ranged from 1 to 5, so additional research is required in order to determine the honeybee’s ability to calculate math consisting of higher numbers. When we think animals and math, usually what comes to mind are horses and chimpanzees, but this research now points to insects incurring the mental capacity of solving mathematical calculations. This new study opens the door to a new understanding about the adaptation and intelligence of some of the smaller creatures on our amazing planet.
Image: AI, the chimpanzee that is able to add. She is also able to count and associate the amount of dots to a numerical value.
Image Credit: Kyoto University
Desktop NewsClick to open Continuous News in a sidebar that updates in real-time.
After brief pause thanks to Nicholas, East Baton Rouge debris removal resumes
Kenilworth Crossing built in hazard flood zone, concerns date back to 2018
Community Fridge created in Baton Rouge to provide free groceries for people...
Clogged drainage systems possible cause of flash flooding in Baton Rouge as...
LaPlace still cleaning up devastation left by Ida